An American Carol
(2008 — Kevin Farley, Kelsey Grammer, Leslie Nielsen)
In the early 1990s, when the Dilbert comic strip was starting to get popular, what made the office humor so funny was the fact that creator Scott Adams would take a silly issue that really occurs at the office and blow it way out of proportion. Adams even unashamedly solicited incidents from fans that he could further lampoon.
However, some time ago, Dilbert ceased being funny because of such caricature. Don’t get me wrong; it’s still often funny. But the humor comes simply from Adams’ style. 21st-century corporate America is impossible to caricature anymore; it has become so unbelievable in reality, that to push its boundaries in fiction would come across with all the sense of order of a Salvador Dali painting.
If there is one cinematic failing of An American Carol, it is a parallel to concept; there are some issues that the movie tackles that are impossible to caricature, but the style sometimes doesn’t make up for that fact. Radio and TV host Glenn Beck said about the movie, “There are uproarious parts to it. And then there are some parts in which it’s obvious that the film-makers were going for laughs, but the issue was too close to reality to actually be funny.”
Case in point: The Michael Malone character (a clear spoof of “documentary“-maker Michael Moore) states, “I love America; that’s why it has to be destroyed.” A ludicrous (and somewhat funny) statement, in and of itself. But it’s an easy extrapolation of actual statements that Moore has made. Fortunately, there are enough moments of extreme caricature that save the movie from these occasions.
An American Carol was directed and co-written by David Zucker of Airplane and The Naked Gun movies. Assuming you like slapstick and sophomoric humor, these were masterpieces. Of late, Zucker has added satire to his bag of tricks, primarily in defense of conservative ideas (or perhaps more accurately, in ridicule of liberal ideas). You can check out YouTube for examples of Zucker’s comedic exposure of the asininity of negotiating with mad-men. In the movie, Zucker revisits and expands on the issues in that second video, paralleling the naivete of Neville Chamberlain with that of those today who think we can just play nice and the terrorists will leave us alone. Zucker has also written and directed some other brief anti-Democrat videos that the RNC admittedly found funny, but refused to use.
The main story of the movie is told by Zucker-movie staple Leslie Nielsen to his grandchildren at a July 4th picnic. In a parallel to Charles Dickens‘ A Christmas Carol, the main character of the story is a very bad person who meets three spirits whose visions convince him to change his ways. Paralleling Scrooge is Kevin Farley’s character, Michael Malone — as stated before, an obvious spoof on Michael Moore, down to the trademark Michigan State “S” ballcap and abundant girth. The three spirits are General George Patton (Kelsey Grammer), George Washingon (Jon Voight) and the angel of death (country music star Trace Adkins, who also appears as himself later in the movie). Malone also has a nephew (merging Bob Cratchit and Scrooge’s nephew, Fred), a young man named Josh, who has enlisted in the navy and is due to ship out on the evening of July 4. Josh (like Cratchit) has a crippled son, Tim.
We later find out that Zucker takes this over the top by introducing us to Josh’s two daughters, one who is blind and cross-eyed and one who is on constant dialysis. All three children have been promised, but not given, help by their uncle.
Having won another director’s award from moovealong.org, Moore sets his sights on leading a movement to abolish Independence Day celebrations in America. The movement is to culminate in a demonstration outside Madison Square Garden, while inside the arena, a concert is put on for American troops and their families (headlined by the afore-mentioned Adkins). It is on the night before this demonstration that the three spirits visit Malone. Announcing the visitation of the spirits (in a parallel to Jacob Marley) is John F Kennedy, who Malone proclaims as his “hero”. Unfortunately, Malone (like many liberals who worship JFK) has conveniently forgotten many of Kennedy’s beliefs that they would be consider to be far-right and anathema. In a throw-away line, Malone tells Kennedy that he’s starting to sound like Ronald Reagan, to which JFK replies, “Thank you.”
Zucker lampoons much of the left’s ideology, from the assumption that terrorism exists because America did something wrong, to the afore-mentioned naivete of negotiation, to “brave” Hollywood directors who tackle no-longer-existing evils of the past but are too cowardly to address current evils such as terrorism. An American Carol also features an appearance by a beret-wearing Rosie O’Connell, who even Malone thinks is nuts. There are also appearances by bumbling terrorists that will certainly get Zucker in trouble with CAIR, but I doubt that he cares (pun intended).
Sidenote: I find it interesting (and funny) that several times is the movie, Malone points out that he is an Oscar-winning director, to which the other person in the conversation scoffs, “Yeah, for a documentary.” An American Carol released the same weekend as an anti-religion slam-job documentary (that I won’t name, as I don’t want to give it even a little Google publicity).
If you can get around the parts that would be offensive to some (which I’ll discuss in a moment) and are of a conservative ilk — or at least have some personal honesty and a funny bone (both of which would disqualify Moore) — An American Carol is a fun movie.
* - * - * - * - * - * - * - * - * - * - * - * -*
Content advisory stuff: Although there are no f-bombs, language is consistent with a PG-13 rating. Unfortunately, like many purveyors of sophomoric comedy, Zucker includes in this some children using foul language. While surprising juxtaposition (in this case, childlike innocence vs foul language) is a staple of comedy, this particular usage of the concept has always struck me as unnecessary. (Granted, though, it is all in insulting characterization of Malone, so half a point to Zucker for accuracy, even if it’s unnecessary.)
There are a few sexual references, including two characters who make a hand-gesture that implies male masturbation and an innocent (but confusing to characters who only hear, and don’t see the context) conversation between two characters. For the latter, think of the misunderstood conversations that were stock in trade in the TV show Three’s Company, only a bit cruder when misinterpreted.
Violence appears occasionally, but it’s generally of a cartoonish nature. If you’re of a mind that the old Looney Tunes were too violent, then the violence in this movie would probably offend you. Though if you are of such a mind, the whole movie would probably offend you, anyway.
Tags:
An American Carol,
Kevin Farley,
Kelsey Grammer,
Leslie Nielsen,
Dilbert,
corporate America,
Glenn Beck,
documentary,
Michael Moore,
David Zucker,
Airplane,
The Naked Gun,
Neville Chamberlain,
Charles Dickens,
A Christmas Carol,
George Patton,
George Washingon,
Trace Adkins,
moovealong.org,
John F Kennedy,
Ronald Reagan