It was the fourth consecutive quarter of losses for Citigroup Inc., but the company might catch a break from investors just for being “less bad” than the usual. Truth be told, expectations for the earnings report were all over the place, ranging from the best-case estimate of a 45-cent loss to a worst-case estimate of a $1.08-per-share loss.
The company reported a net loss of $2.81 billion, or 60 cents a share, compared with prior-year net income of $2.21 billion, or 44 cents a share. Revenue fell 23% to $16.7 billion. It wrote down an additional $4.4 billion in bad debts, characterizing the losses as the result of “the impact of a difficult economic environment and weak capital markets.”
The company is holding its earnings conference call, hosted by Gary Crittenden, chief financial officer. CEO Vikram Pandit is not on the call.
10:04 a.m.: The call is beginning. Mr. Crittenden is going through the slide presentation, highlighting the losses.
10:07 a.m.: The company’s net interest margin has improved in recent quarters — 3.14% in the second quarter, and 3.13% in the third quarter. At this time last year, net interest margin was 2.34%. Mr. Crittenden cites the Fed’s rate cuts, and it’s clear that the recent activity from the Fed should at least help banks get back to the business of borrowing short and lending long.
10:11 a.m.: “Sequentially, expenses declined for the third quarter in a row,” he says. In addition, year-over-year headcount fell by 5%. The company has cut, or will cut, 22,000 jobs in the last year.
10:14 a.m.: Total cost of credit increased by $4.2 billion, or nearly 50%, from the year-earlier period. This includes $1.7 billion for higher loan loss reserve builds and $2.5 billion in net credit losses. As unemployment has risen, net credit loss ratios have increased to a rate of 7.13% and are rising more quickly than in the 1991-1992 period. For the company’s North American credit-card division, and has risen to 2.16% for first mortgages. Mr. Crittenden says credit-card loss ratios could continue to rise in 2009, and he notes that mortgage-related losses may continue to rise, as they have “longer tails” — that is, it takes longer for those losses to play out.
10:21 a.m.: Much of the increases in net credit losses come from three countries — Mexico, Brazil and India — they’re responsible for 74% of the increase in net credit losses.

10:23 a.m.: The losses of the past quarter have again damaged the company’s Tier-1 Capital Ratio, a key measure of banking health. That ratio fell to 8.2% in the third quarter, down from 8.7% in the second quarter. Still, it’s an improvement on a year-over-year basis, from 7.3% for the third quarter 2008.
10:31 a.m.: The company took $800 million in write-downs in exposure to asset-backed commercial paper, and reduced subprime exposure to $19.6 billion from $22.5 billion. Total write-downs came to $1.7 billion, and the company also recorded sales, transfers or restructurings to the tune of $2.1 billion.
10:35 a.m.: The company’s direct subprime exposure breaks down as follows: $23.4 billion in asset-backed commercial paper, which has been marked down by 57% to a market value of $13.3 billion. The company also has $2.8 billion in high-grade subprime exposure, now worth $1.1 billion, and mezzanine debt, worth $1.7 billion (down from $8 billion). Mr. Crittenden’s voice is starting to become wearying.
10:40 a.m.: The company has taken significant marks on its exposures to structured investment vehicles (82%), commercial real estate (86%), and auction-rate securities (78%).
10:44 a.m.: Discussing continued volatility in fixed-income markets, Mr. Crittenden says the firm is “managing this by lowering our risk positions aggressively which has resulted in lower marks for the third consecutive quarter.” He mentions layoffs, but of course calls them by the unfortunate term, “right-sizing.”
10:46 a.m.: Time for questions! First up is John McDonald of Sanford Bernstein is first. He asks about the government’s preferred investments, and where that puts them in terms of the limit they can issue in such preferreds. But Mr. Crittenden says it’s a moot point because it factors into Tier 1 Capital.
He also wants to know about rising losses in credit due to where they’ve been growing fast and areas where economic stress are hitting credit losses. Mr. Crittenden refers to the slide presentation, saying credit was growing rapidly around the world, but he believes that most of the declines are economic-related. The losses are confined, however, to places like India, Brazil and Mexico. “There is some deterioration in credit broadly,” says Mr. Crittenden.