Winners & Losers From the Week That Was
XM-Sirius: We could almost hear Mel Karmazin cracking the champagne from here. The 520 day wait is finally over. The FCC this week reached an agreement to approve the merger of the two satellite radio companies. Now, the hard part begins — integrating the two firms and competing in a environment that is quickly changing.
Ken Wilson: When the President calls and offers you a job saving the country, it is hard to say no. And Goldman Sachs’s most senior financial-institutions banker didn’t. Wilson is temporarily leaving the firm to advise Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson on how to resolve the country’s banking crisis. Few seem better prepared. After all, he has already advised on most of the big deals that have saved financial institutions this past year.
Swiss M&A: From Roche-Genentech to Novartis-Alcon and the spinoff of Philip Morris International (based in Switzerland), one thing is clear — Swiss firms have become deal making enthusiasts in 2008. Mergers and acquisitions involving a Swiss company account for 22.5% of all European deals this year, compared with 4% for all of last year.
Wachovia: Can the Charlotte-based bank’s $25.5 billion acquisition of Golden West Financial officially be called a deal from hell? Wachovia/Golden West now seems to qualify, if only because of the destruction of market value. At the time of the deal, Wachovia had a market cap of $90.2 billion and predicted that with Golden West its combined market cap would be $117 billion. Wachovia’s market cap hit $25.87 billion this week and is hovering just above $30 billion today, or not much more than Wachovia paid to acquire Golden West.
Cleveland-Cliffs: By not consulting its largest shareholder, Harbinger Capital, before unveiling its $10 billion deal for Alpha Natural Resources, Cleveland-Cliffs faces the likelihood that its deal for Alpha won’t be approved and may have inadvertently put itself in play.
Roche: The Swiss drug maker’s offer to acquire the roughly 44% of Genentech it didn’t already own fell flat. At $89 a share, the offer marked just an 8% premium. Now, Genentech is standing up for itself, shares closed at $96 and a shareholder lawsuit has been filed. And as this Deal Journal post explains, negotiations already were fraught with plenty of issues. Perhaps biggest among them is keeping Genentech’s talent.
Microsoft-Yahoo: Now that Yahoo and Carl Icahn have made peace and Microsoft has washed its hands of the deal, it is time to ask this question: Has any takeover battle left the two firms involved looking so bad. See this Deal Journal post and this one for more.
Why should they have consulted their largest share holder at this point. that should come later.Part of the difficulty these days is that the poor sucker average shareholders often do not know what is going on unltil the decisions are made. Doesn’t CLF have a board which is charged with making these decisions? Harbinger is not playing hard ball, they are playing cheat ball with a selfish and self-serving orientation.
On the subject of winners and losers, I have a couple of questions for the people who criticize and slander Uncle George and the American way of life:
Why don’t you move to China or Canada if you’re not happy in the United States?
Do you have any better ideas–what do you recommend, a communist dictatorship?
You folks seem to be doing pretty well–you’re not in any concentration camps.
America isn’t perfect, but it’s the best there is–because it works.
Be honest, what you say boils done to one thing: It’s a case of the pot calling the kettle black.
And that doesn’t make any sense.
You’d better go back to the drawing-board . . .
God bless America and God bless the civilization of the American peoples–rock of the age.
UP–bailouts of all stripes–the airlines are next.
DOWN–Paulson, Congress for facilitating the largest bailout in history without so much as a wimper or cogent analysis/ debate. In view of the credit spread reaction and the S&P downgrades–this one is a very expensive.
Christopher,
You are a very scary automaton, er, I mean man.
Handsome is as handsome does.
Forgetfulness is the danger of our times . . .
God bless America and God bless the civilization of the American peoples–rock of the age.
with FCC approval in hand, Mel can proceed with his secret plan for world domination at the helm of SIRI/XM; contrary to the 2 DEMS at the FCC, that will not materialize. But at least the agony of the wait is complete. Now the agony that follows is whether all the hype was worth it. I’d hate to be in admin at either company right now…pink slips a-coming
Wacky Bank strikes again!






Deal Journal is an up-to-the-minute take on deals and deal-makers, updated frequently with exclusive running commentary, news flashes, profiles, data and more. The Wall Street Journal's Heidi N. Moore and Dennis Berman are the lead writers, with contributions from other Journal reporters. Send news items, comments and questions to 
